page two [June – September]
These highlights chronicle the year 2018. Created incrementally as new photos were available, the year runs generally "backwards" on this page. Unlike earlier years, many highlights have been limited to the exceptional rarities. The abbreviation "MTY" means "Monterey County" in the text below. Text by Don Roberson. Photos on this page are copyrighted by the photographers to whom they are attributed, and may not be reproduced in any form (including other web sites) without the express consent of the photographer.

In an autumn full of surprises, one of the most unexpected was documented by a visitor from New York State during a field trip, looking for condors, offered by the annual Monterey Bay Bird Festival in Watsonville. At a stop at Grimes Point on the Big Sur coast on 29 Sep, Suzanne O'Rourke wandered over to some blooming Salvia and snapped this photograph of a young male Broad-billed Hummingbird! (photo left 29 Sep © Suzanne O'Rourke). By the time the rest of the birders on the trip got to the spot, the hummer had vanished and was never seen again.

This was just the second record for this Mexican hummingbird in MTY. In a touch of irony, Bob Tintle and Chris Tenney discovered the first county record at the Carmel River mouth exactly 34 years earlier — on 29 Sep 1984. That individual hung around a blooming mallow at at "Rio Park," behind the Carmel Mission, for two days. [Tintle's photo of that young male is in the first edition of Monterey Birds.]

Birders were luckier with another rarity in late September — this young female Bay-breasted Warbler at Pt. Pinos, found by Blake Matheson on 22 Sep, that lingered through 26 Sep and was photographed by many (photo right 23 Sep © Bill Hill). Note the lime-green crown and back and the black legs and feet that help separate it from hatch-year Blackpoll Warblers.

A week earlier, on 15 Sep, visiting tour leader Mary Gustafson found another hatch-year female at Moonglow Dairy. The only year we've never had two different Bay-breasts in MTY on the same year was in 1985.

This now makes eight MTY records, all in fall migration. The two records this fall, plus a young male at the Pacific Grove cemetery 20-25 Sep 2014, are the only ones from this century — and the only ones from September. All prior records were in October to early December.

There was also a fine flight of raptors this September. Five reports of young Bald Eagles from Pt. Pinos to Monterey harbor to Jacks Peak was extraordinary (even if some of them were the same individual moving about). Three Swainson's Hawks around Jacks Peak in September, and another well up Carmel Valley, were unexpected. Perhaps best of all, there were 7 imm Broad-winged Hawks scattered from Pacific Grove and Carmel to Jacks Peak between 23 Sep-1 Nov (photo left, juv 23 Sep over P.G. cemetery © Blake Matheson). This small eastern Buteo was once more regular in MTY as a rare wintering species — and kettles of up to 17 Broad-wings appeared over Pacific Grove on 2 Nov 1982 — so that this September movement brought back recollections of the "glory years" in the past century.
The Frog Pond Nature Preserve in Del Rey Oaks has a small pond (dry this autumn) and lovely trails through willow and live oak woodlands. It is a fine spot for birding but has never been known for attracting major rarities. That changed this fall, starting with finds by Rita Carratello and Hugo Ceja (lefthand two birders below, with Robert Horn and Bill Hill to the right).
The first vagrant was a Virginia's Warbler, found 11 Sep by Rita Carratello while leading an adult education class on birding (above, photo 11 Sep © Rita Carratello). She texted Don Roberson, who chased the Virginia (and dipped) but discovered a hatch-year Canada Warbler (right, photo 11 Sep © D. Roberson). Rita was back at Frog Pond on 14 Sep, ran into Hugo Ceja, and together they found a Philadelphia Vireo (below left, photo 14 Sep © Hugo Ceja) and a imm female Chestnut-sided Warbler (below right, photo 14 Sep © Hugo Ceja). By then the word was out and caravans of birders headed to the Frog Pond, some from as far away as Sacramento and Washington State. Like the proverbial "Patagonia Rest Stop," new rarities were located, including two Indigo Bunting (male in body molt at bottom left, photo 14 Sep © D. Roberson) and 1-2 Black-and-white Warbler (bottom right, photo 15 Sep © D. Roberson). There were also a Tennessee Warbler, a Summer Tanager, and several Willow Flycatchers. Each vagrant lingered at its own pace — two in this gallery remained to 22 Sep. And then the Frog Pond grew quiet, returning to obscurity.

Autumn rarities started early in 2018. Surprisingly, they began with a run of adult vagrant passerines — this is a surprise because more than 90% of fall vagrants are hatch-year birds in their first migration. The best was a Gray Catbird discovered by the remarkable Bill Hill on 28 August (photo right 28 Aug © Bill Hill). It took up residence in a riparian thicket, eating creek dogwood berries and occasionally singing or giving its 'mew' call. You can see from Bill's photo that an outer rectrix is growing in on 28 Aug. When we saw it on 9 Sep, the tail seemed complete. It seems this bird was present to molt before moving south. Did it summer here? Or is this an example of "molt migration" — adults moving away from the breeding locale to another spot to molt before migrating, something that is documented in eastern passerines and is currently being studied (fide Scott Terrill).

It's been a long time since there was a 'chaseable' Gray Catbird in MTY, so all the locals put on rubber boots to wade to see it. The last one at the Carmel River was back on 7-8 June 1997. That Catbird was discovered by — drum roll — Bill Hill. Long before digital cameras, MTY has been blessed with excellent photographers who documented local rarities. In the 1960s-1970s it was Ron Branson. In the 1980s, John Sorensen. And from about the 1990s, the go-to guy has been Bill Hill. Now with digital cameras we have several fine photographers, but Bill is a local lad who grew up to be the Carmel Fire Chief until retirement gave him more time to photograph birds.

Two unexpected vireos also proved to be adults. Brian Sullivan found this scruffy Yellow-green Vireo (below left, photo 28 Aug © B.L. Sullivan) in Pacific Grove's "El Carmelo" cemetery on 28 Aug. We can tell it is an adult by the red eye. It was very elusive but was seen to 3 Sep. Carole Rose found this worn and beat-up Red-eyed Vireo — with its adult red eye — in Monterey's "San Carlos" cemetery on 5 Sep (photo below right © C. Rose). Yellow-green is the rarer of the two 'red-eyed' vireos in MTY, with just 11 records. We now average about 1-2 Red-eyed Vireos a year, and the species has attempted to summer at Big Sur River mouth. Remarkably, two vagrant hatch-year Red-eyed Vireos — with dark eyes — have already been one-day-wonders this fall.

Another potential adult vagrant was this Blackburnian Warbler, found by Rick Fournier at Pt. Pinos on 5-6 Sep (photo right 5 Sep © D. Roberson). Rick thought it was a worn adult female, and details of the amount and shape of the white tips that create the two wingbars further support the theory (per Pyle's 1997 banding guide).

Michael Rieser found a more typical hatch-year Blackburnian at the Presidio of Monterey on 6 Sep. From a MTY perspective, these are the two earliest fall Blackburnians on record. Most of MTY's records are from October.

Two small Spizella sparrows sparked discussion as well. On 6 Sep Paul Fenwick found this Brewer's Sparrow at the Pacific Grove cemetery (below left, photo 6 Sep © D. Roberson), and it remained to 7 Sep. There is only one earlier fall record in MTY (5 Sep 1979 near Robinson Canyon, Rich Stallcup), and one other from 7 Sep (in 2009 at Salinas WTP, Scott & Linda Terrill). But it was not so much the early arrival that was curious. Birders noted that at certain angles the extensive soft-gray half-collar of the P.G. bird was more extensive than typical, and the face more patterned, bringing to mind the possibility of "Timberline Sparrow." Described as a separate species by Swath & Brooks in 1925, "Timberline Sparrow" breeds in isolated populations at subalpine elevations in the Rockies of s.e. Alaska to s.w. Alberta. It is currently considered a subspecies of Brewer's Sparrow: S. b. taverneri. It apparently migrates to the winter range of nominate Brewer's Sparrow, and there is said to be a specimen from California (Rotenbery et al. 1999). Otherwise, there is very little known about it.
   We'll probably never know if the P.G. cemetery sparrow was a "Timberline Sparrow." The odds are against it. We can, however, compare it with a presumed nominate S. b. breweri Brewer's Sparrow that was found by Rita Carratello at Pt. Lobos on 8 Sep, becoming the 4th earliest ever (photo below right © Carol Greenstreet).

There was also a run of other eastern warblers from the last days of August into early September: the earliest ever MTY Canada Warbler on 31 Aug at Big Sur R. mouth (photo below left © Paul Fenwick), several Chestnut-sided and Tennessee Warblers and American Redstarts, an adult Black-and-white Warbler, and a Northern Parula. Also, during the two week span between 28 Aug–9 Sep, about 21 Willow Flycatchers were found in MTY [including this hatch-year bird, below right, so beautifully captured by Brian Sullivan on 28 Aug at the P.G. cemetery, © B.L. Sullivan]. Up to 4 in a day were at Hot Spots like the P.G. cemetery (28 Aug), the Carmel River mouth (30 Aug), and the Big Sur River mouth (2 Sep). The most ever found in a single fall migration was 23 during autumn 1998. We already have 21 tallied in just two weeks . . .[Update: after the full date span of 26 Aug–25 Sep 2018, the best estimate was 33 Willow Flycatchers at 10 locations!].
Tropical seabird! Meanwhile, offshore, a mix of warm water and other criteria suggest that an El Niño might be forming in the tropical Pacific. Whether it appears or not, Monterey Bay is starting to show more signs of changing time. On 1 September, while looking from Pt. Pinos with a new space-age scope, Blake Matheson watched and described a light-morph Wedge-tailed Shearwater fly past. There are just 3 MTY records for this tropical seabird, all more-or-less associated with El Niños. The first was also a light-morph bird on August 31, 1986, about 4 miles west of Pt. Pinos (Stallcup et al. 1998).

More tropical boobies! Farther down this page you'll find that the top highlights of summer 2018 were tropical boobies usually limited to warmer seas in the eastern tropical Pacific. Two more were headlines in August. On 25 August, Brian Sullivan watched this immature dark-morph Red-footed Booby fly past Pt. Pinos while Brian was sea-watching — and he even managed a few photos! (photo right © B.L. Sullivan). This is just the 5th record for MTY.

On 24 August — the day before the Pt. Pinos Red-footed Booby — a larger and more controversial booby was a few miles west of Pt. Pinos, found from a Shearwater Journeys pelagic trip (both photos below © Alex Lamoreaux; in the upper photo the booby is harassed by an imm Heermann's Gull). It is clearly a young booby just beginning post-juvenal wing molt (at innermost primary) and undergoing body molt on the head, neck, and upperwing coverts.

Some have labeled it "Masked Booby," largely on bill color, but the more recent trend in analysis leans towards Nazca Booby (as does this commentator). As you see down the page, there are 6 recent records of Nazca in MTY — and an amazing influx off southern California.

Note that only the distal half of the bill is yellow (and a small stripe along the cutting edge), but the basal half is essentially bone-white. A half-yellow bill is just fine for Nazca — it is the color at the base of the bill that separates Masked from Nazca. The state of molt of this booby suggests it is about a year old. Some observers now think that perhaps only Nazca Booby can have a chalky-white base to the bill a year after it is hatched — perhaps Masked Booby should have a more completely yellow or yellow-green bill by this age. More study is needed.

However, a plumage character might be important at this age. The vast majority of Masked Booby populations around the globe have a white cervical collar at the base of the neck in young birds from juvenal plumage onwards. There is the possibility that some percentage of young Masked Boobies hatched on Clipperton Island may lack the collar (see Roberson 1998). In contrast, the strong majority of juvenal-plumaged Nazca Boobies lack the white collar [again, with a few exceptions]. Clearly, the presence or absence of a cervical collar separates the vast majority of young Nazca/Masked Boobies.

It is now suggested that by the time a subadult booby of this type is in post-juvenal body molt, all subadult Masked Boobies should have a white collar. Here, in the two photos at right, are Masked Boobies at about the one-year-age category from the eastern tropical Pacific: the upper photo was taken 2 Aug 1989 at 19'20N,114'50W (in old non-digital lat-long terminology). The lower photo at right was taken 7 Sep 1989 at 4'55N,138'41W [both photos © D. Roberson, digitized from slides].

The upper booby (at right) has head and neck molt fairly similar to August 2018 bird in Monterey Bay; it has a broad cervical collar of Masked Booby. The Monterey Bay booby lacks that collar entirely. The lower Masked Booby(at right) has more advanced body molt than the Monterey Bay booby but the white spots on upperwing coverts are similar and wing molt looks close. That bird obviously has much white covering the entire cervical area.

At the current state of knowledge, I think the evidence supports the identification of the 24 Aug 2018 bird as a Nazca Booby. See also my discussion about last July's booby at Pt. Pinos, which I also believe was a subadult Nazca Booby.

Summer 2018, at least along the coast, was cold and foggy much of the time, while interior temperatures were scorching. Few vagrants occurred during summer, except some fine seabirds (below); an exception was a Brown Thrasher briefly in a Pacific Grove yard on 23 June (Blake T. Matheson). By mid-August, though, a few interesting landbird migrants appeared on the Monterey Peninsula. Carole Rose found both of these: an imm male Costa's Hummingbird in her yard in the Skyline Forest area of Monterey (below left, photo 17 Aug © Carole Rose) and a Tennessee Warbler in Pacific Grove's El Carmelo cemetery (below right, photo 16 Aug © C. Rose; with an Orange-crowned Warbler).
    Costa's Hummingbirds breed locally in southern MTY but are quite rare on the Monterey Peninsula. This one first appeared in the Roses' yard on 4 Aug, The young male has been molting in its violet gorget since then as he defends a small patch of planted Mexican sage.
    The Tennessee Warbler record is unusual in several ways. First, it is remarkable that Carole got both the Tennessee and and an Orange-crowned Warbler in the same photo. The photo illustrates some of the important structural differences between these two warblers: Tennessee is smaller, much shorter-tailed but longer-winged, and much shorter-billed than Orange-crowned. These differences are more important on imm Tennessee Warblers which are yellow below (but for white undertail coverts). This August's Tennessee was an adult (probably a female), and that is also unusual. Most vagrant Tennessees are hatch-year birds later in fall migration. Did this adult Tennessee summer locally? Or is it a very early migrant? There are only two prior records in summer, both at Big Sur R. mouth: 16 July 1998 (Jim Booker) and 22 Aug 2015 (Alex Rinkert).

Carole and Larry Rose also found this female Hermit Warbler at Pt. Pinos on 17 Aug (photo left © Rita Carratello; the warbler has captured a bug), but it was a part of a larger phenomena involving this species. Hermit Warbler winters here in MTY regularly in small numbers, and is a scarce spring and fall migrant. The nearest known breeders are in the Santa Cruz Mountains. However, singing males have been present in Ponderosa pine habitat in late May and June in the Santa Lucia Mountains, and during the Breeding Bird Atlas, a fresh juv was observed on Anderson Peak above Big Sur (17 July 1992, D. Roberson, R. Carratello). This strongly suggests that some local nesting occurs.

This summer, a fresh juv was near Jacks Peak on 30 July (Blake Matheson), suggesting breeding nearby. On 31 July, a bright imm visited a backyard in Pacific Grove (Rita Carratello). Two more very early migrants were seen in Pacific Grove on 14-15 Aug (Gary Dial, Bruce Mast). There are a few other migrant records in August (see Monterey Birds, 2d ed.) but the Pt. Pinos bird brings our summer total to 5 Hermits, which is indeed unusual.

The summer's biggest news involved boobies from tropical seas. The first was a subadult Nazca Booby seen initially on Monterey Bay on 24 June by Don Bacchus, Jim Scarff, and Kate Spencer from FastRaft. This same individual was seen and photographed again on 26 June from Discovery Whale Watch (photo below 26 June © Eric Austin Yee). There are now 6 records in MTY. Nazca Booby is primarily a bird of the Galapagos Islands and all of California's records have occurred during this century. There have been multiple Nazca Boobies in southern CA waters this past spring and summer. Given this sea-change in distribution, one might think that some sort of warming trend in the global climate might be underway.

More unexpected was the presence of two subadult Red-footed Boobies in MTY this summer. The first was found dead, washed up on Moss Landing SB, on 1 July (photo right © Ryan Carle). It appeared to be emaciated and perhaps died of starvation. In tropical seas, Red-footed Boobies forage far offshore — often chasing and catching flying fish — but perhaps there is not enough surface fish in Monterey Bay to support their foraging strategy? Red-foots are also notorious for their habitat of resting and sleeping on anything that is floating on the sea: flotsam, kelp, sea turtles (dead or alive), and (most often) ships. When I spent 4 months at sea as a NOAA naturalist, one Red-footed Booby rode on our research ship for 5 days and hundreds of miles, sleeping on the mast each night, until we could see Hawaii in the distance.

In California — and before Nazca was split from Masked Booby as a species — Red-footed was the rarest of all State boobies. Until recently, except for an incursion in fall 1987, there had never been more than 1-2 in any year. From Aug-Dec 1987 at least six reached California, four of which were in central California). MTY's first records were in that incursion.

During 2017 & 2018 so far, at least a half-dozen Red-footed Boobies have been seen on-shore or offshore in southern California. But the most visited by birders was one at Pillar Point Harbor in San Mateo County from 29 Oct-13 Dec 2017. July's specimen from Moss Landing added another.

Then, on Sunday afternoon 12 August, Kate Cummings of Blue Ocean Whale Watch was heading out of Moss Landing harbor aboard "High Spirits" when she spotted this Red-footed Booby riding on the bow of the fishing boat "Fishore," which was heading into the harbor (photo below 12 Aug © Kate Cummings). It had presumably landed on that boat somewhere in Monterey Bay that day.

When the Blue Ocean whale watch returned to the harbor at 5 p.m., Kate Cummings spotted the booby roosting on a sailboat moored in Moss Landing marina. It was still there on Monday morning when seen by many local birders (photo left 13 Aug © D. Roberson). It was apparent that this subadult Red-footed Booby was either very tired or was ill. At mid-day it fell from the mast to the deck of the sailboat. Monterey SPCA was called and they took it to their Wildlife Rescue Center. Tests showed it was emaciated with no protein in its blood. Despite giving it food and meds, the booby died overnight (fide Corey Utter).

Both of MTY's Red-footed Boobies from this summer will be necropsied by California Fish & Game to determine the cause of death. It has been arranged that both will likely become specimens in a major California museum (fide Steve Hampton). California has at least two prior specimens in museums, "both are relatively small and dark, consistent with Red-footed Booby populations in the eastern Pacific" (CBRC 2007).

Literature cited:

  • California Birds Records Committee. 2007. Rare Birds of California.
  • Roberson, D. 1998. Sulids Unmasked: which large booby reaches California? Field Notes 52: 276-287. [on-line]
  • Roberson, D. 2002. Monterey Birds. 2d ed. Monterey Audubon Society, Carmel, CA.
  • Rotenberry, J. T., M. A. Patten, and K. L. Preston (1999). Brewer's Sparrow (Spizella breweri), version 2.0. In The Birds of North America (A. F. Poole and F. B. Gill, Editors). Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Ithaca, NY, USA.
  • Stallcup, R., J. Morlan, and D. Roberson 1998. First record of the Wedge-tailed Shearwater in California. Western Birds 19: 61-68.






Page created 19 Aug 2018, updated 8 Nov 2018